Gold and Silver's Deepening Dollar Dilemma

feature image
  • US financial conditions tighten at exceptional pace
  • Gold and silver suffer historically severe selloffs
  • Dollar sensitivity approaches multi-decade historical extremes
  • Bearish technicals suggest further downside remains possible

Gold and silver were smashed again on Thursday as risk appetite reversed sharply alongside Anthropic's blockbuster IPO. While the company's shares finished comfortably above their offer price, the broader tech sector slumped as concerns about the eventual returns from the AI capex boom continued to weigh on sentiment.

But what if the pressure we're seeing in tech is only part of a much broader problem? Our US financial conditions proxy points to a rapid tightening that may help explain why volatility is spreading across asset classes, including precious metals. And as our updated historical analysis reveals, what's happening in gold and silver right now is extraordinary, even when compared with previous periods of severe market stress.

US financial conditions tightening accelerates

Our model, which aims to replicate the Fed's Financial Conditions Impulse on Growth (FCI-G), is shown below. For those unfamiliar with it, the measure combines seven financial market variables to assess whether conditions are supportive or restrictive for economic activity, with obvious implications for the performance of different asset classes.

image-20261120102702-6

Source: LSEG, TradingView

While our model suggests financial conditions remain accommodative, what can't be ignored is the speed at which that accommodation is being withdrawn. Over the past 40 trading sessions, the measure has risen 0.487 points, a pace of tightening exceeded in just 2.6% of comparable periods since April 2009.

To put this into perspective, moves of this magnitude have typically occurred during periods of severe market stress, such as the onset of the coronavirus pandemic in early 2020 and the Liberation Day tariff announcement in April 2025.

Gold and silver crushed as financial conditions tighten

image-20261120102733-7

Source: LSEG, TradingView

The impact on precious metals from the unwind of accommodation shown in our model has been simply brutal. Since 22 September, gold has tanked 16.7%, while silver has plunged by more than double, sliding 35.7%. Both declines are larger than those witnessed during any of the 10 previous episodes of rapid tightening identified since 2009.

Not only has the scale of these declines been unprecedented across the episodes studied, but it's also notable that gold's safe-haven characteristics appear to have shifted. Gold actually rose during six prior rapid tightening episodes, whereas more recently, the exact opposite has taken place. The only exception was the Liberation Day tariff announcement in April 2025, when the US dollar was broadly weaker amid the temporary 'sell USA' trade.

image-20261120102749-8

Source: LSEG, TradingView

Declines in silver are far more common during these episodes, likely reflecting not only its highly speculative characteristics but also its links to the industrial side of the global economy.

Dollar breakout compounds pressure on precious metals

As discussed in a short analysis piece earlier this week, the US dollar staged a dramatic bullish breakout earlier this month, hitting levels not seen since April 2025. That move is especially problematic for gold and silver given just how sensitive both metals have become to movements in the big dollar over the past year.

image-20261120102630-4

Source: LSEG, TradingView

Using daily data going back more than five decades, gold's 252-session beta to DXY of −2.54 is the 38th most negative observation since 1972, exceeded only during the precious metals turmoil in 1980 and briefly earlier this week. For silver, the reading is even more extreme. Its beta of −5.62 is the third most negative since 1983, with the only two more extreme readings occurring earlier this month.

image-20261120102603-3

Source: LSEG, TradingView

To put those figures into perspective, a 1% rise in DXY has been associated with a roughly 2.54% decline in gold and a 5.62% fall in silver over the past 252 trading sessions. The reverse applies when the dollar weakens. Of course, these are historical statistical relationships and can change over time. But the current readings highlight just how sensitive both silver and gold have become to shifts in the dollar over the past year.

As discussed previously, while DXY may be due a period of consolidation after such a strong run, from a fundamental perspective, unless the Fed backs away from its hawkish stance or US economic data starts to roll over, it's difficult to make the near-term case for a sustained dollar reversal. An outcome that could leave precious metals stuck in the pressure cooker for a while longer.

This content was created by an affiliate of FOREX.com and represents the views and opinions of the author/speakers, not the views and opinions of FOREX.com, StoneX Group Inc., or its subsidiaries. The content has not been independently reviewed by FOREX.com.

Gold slide turns violent

image-20261120102539-2

Source: TradingView

After repeatedly attracting buyers beneath $4,000 in June and July, and again in October, gold's inability to hold above that level, let alone challenge its medium and long-term moving averages, has given way to an abrupt unwind as financial conditions tighten.

Since 10 November, the price action has been outright ugly. Gold has plunged more than $500, falling from $4,147 to around $3,625, slicing through the late-October lows near $3,870 before motoring through a series of minor support levels.

Looking at the bigger picture, the next level of note is the 50% retracement of the massive bull run from September 2022 to January 2026, which saw gold surge from around $1,615 to $5,600. That retracement sits near $3,607, just beneath where the price currently trades. While gold hasn't shown much respect for retracement levels previously, it's one to monitor given the scale of the move.

Below that, $3,579 is another minor level of note, followed by the former record high of $3,500 set in April 2025. Gold spent six months struggling to overcome that level before eventually staging a massive bullish breakout.

Nothing is a certainty in markets, but given the current trajectory, the price appears to be on a collision course with $3,500. The momentum indicators are certainly on board with that view. RSI (14) has printed a fresh lower low near 26, suggesting downside momentum continues to build, while MACD has staged a bearish crossover, diverging further from its signal line and confirming the bearish message.

Yes, the move is stretched and prone to a short-term squeeze, as witnessed intraday on Thursday. But right now, the path of least resistance still looks lower. With US financial conditions tightening rapidly, the abrupt nature of this unwind reeks of a shortage of US dollar liquidity, potentially explaining why the selling has become so violent.

Silver smoked

image-20261120102520-1

Source: TradingView

The unwind in silver has been even more extreme than gold, with the price now in a strong bear market, trading well below its key medium and long-term moving averages and keeling over like a ship going under.

After failing to reclaim $54.50 earlier this month, the selling pressure has been relentless. Former support at $48.65 and the nearby 78.6% Fib of the April 2025 to January 2026 bull run at $48.32 have both given way, triggering another accelerated move lower.

That has brought the price back towards $42.97, a former resistance level that acted as a breakout zone during the bull run in the second half of 2025. Just beneath $41, a rising trend line extending from the February 2024 lows is another level of note, although it has yet to register the three touches needed to establish it as more reliable trend support. Below that, $39.53 is another former breakout level to watch.

Like the price action, the oscillators remain firmly bearish, although there's one minor development worth watching. Despite the latest unwind, RSI (14) has not printed a fresh lower low relative to October. That suggests downside momentum may not be building with quite the same intensity, although it's certainly not a signal to act upon at this stage. RSI may yet make a fresh low, but it hasn't been confirmed.

MACD continues to deliver a bearish message, having staged another crossover in negative territory and now diverging further beneath its signal line. The bearish bias remains very much intact.

As with gold, the move is stretched and vulnerable to sudden short squeezes. Should we see a rebound, $46.55 is the first level of note, followed by the 78.6% Fib at $48.32 and former support at $48.65. Until the price can reclaim these levels, the bears remain firmly in control.

Open an account in minutes

Experience award-winning platforms with fast and secure execution.

Live Trading Webinars

Our interactive webinars, led by our industry experts, come highly recommended and can help provide your trading with the edge it needs.
Economic Calendar